True Story: We’re Trying To Foster-To-Adopt

What's it like to foster-to-adopt? How is it different from international adoption? Easier? Harder? Click through for one family's story

Erin and her husband, Erin’s boys with the baby they were fostering

What’s it like to foster-to-adopt? How is it different from international adoption? Easier? Harder? A totally different animal? Today my longtime internet friend Erin shares her family’s journey of trying to foster-to-adopt

Tell us a bit about yourself! 

My name is Erin Etheridge. I grew up in Los Angeles and Chicago, but married a very un-Southern Southern guy named Noah. We ended up back here in his hometown of Winston-Salem, North Carolina. Over the past ten years, we’ve turned our little suburban home into a Fun-Size Farm. I’m a freelance writer/editor, a professional-level unpaid reader of books, and a stay-at-home mom to two boys: Ethan, who is 9, and Oliver, who is 4.

You have two biological sons. What interests you about expanding your family through adoption rather than by having another biological child?

Pregnancy was really hard for me. I loved being pregnant—it’s such a unique experience—but I had some pretty serious conditions both times (hence the big age gap between kids). The first time, I developed intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy, and the second time I had hyperemesis gravidarum and gestational diabetes AND cholestasis of pregnancy. Basically, I was terribly uncomfortable and ill for much of both pregnancies.

We still felt like we wanted more kids, and I’ve had family members and close friends who were adopted, so it always felt like just another normal way to make a family.

There are lots of ways for people to expand their families through adoption. What appealed to you about fostering-to-adopt?

We decided on foster-to-adopt for a lot of reasons. Ultimately, we just want another child or children to love. There are benefits and drawbacks to every type of adoption. For us, the benefits of foster-to-adopt outweighed other options.

For one thing, the child/children would be from our own community or nearby. In a way, they wouldn’t be losing absolutely everything they knew before.

Our community is very diverse and our child-hunger rate is among the highest in the country. All of that translates to more fragile families and families in crisis right here, where we live. So not only would we have the opportunity to grow our family, we’d be contributing to an important and always over-burdened public service.

Finally, foster-to-adopt is financially affordable. It virtually costs nothing additional to actually raising the child, unlike international or private adoptions, which have many expensive fees for a lot of reasons.

How does a family prepare to foster a child?

In our state, families (whether couples or singles) go through an extensive training process. We opted to partner with The Crossnore School and Children’s Home, which adds another layer of advocacy and support, but also requires much more training (which I think is a great thing!).

Crossnore uses a sanctuary model, meaning we are a trauma-informed organization. We do a lot of work learning about trauma and how it affects people, and also how to help traumatized kids move forward.

We did a ton of paperwork, background checks, home visits, a fire inspection, and also worked on determining our “criteria” (basically deciding what age range, gender, race/ethnicity, and religion we could comfortably handle as a family). Our home has to be deemed safe, and we have to have a bed and/or crib ready, as well as dedicated drawer and closet space, for any potential kids.

Foster care gets a bad rep for a lot of real reasons, but it’s important that the general public realizes how much goes into becoming a foster parent nowadays—which is ultimately a volunteer service.

If we have a child placed with us, we get a financial stipend that is basically just enough to cover food and clothing. We’d be provided certain services for free (since every child in foster care gets Medicaid), and a voucher for daycare if necessary, but this is not a money-making game.

Are you specifically hoping to adopt an infant? Or are you open to older kids?

Originally we thought a child between the ages of 4 and 7 would fit well into our family (either gender, any race). They’d be right in between our biological kids, so the birth order wouldn’t change. But once you start fostering, you realize that your criteria helps you make decisions (you NEVER have to say yes to a potential placement) but it’s not like picking a kid out of a catalog.

When we got a call about a two-month-old boy, our criteria went out the window. We said yes right away. Now I can see how we could be open to a child of just about any age.

How much does the foster program tell you about a foster child and their background before they place them with you? Have you ever encountered a situation where you were hesitant to accept a placement?

The agency is supposed to tell you everything they know. (DSS, CPS, DCFS, choose your acronym, they’re different everywhere, but whoever your social workers are, that’s “the agency.”) Unfortunately, a lot of times they don’t know much. If it’s an emergency placement, the circumstances of the child’s being taken into custody are likely dramatic and swift.

We’ve encountered two situations where we were hesitant to accept a placement, and ultimately didn’t. In one, the child came from a very large sibling group and the family situation seemed particularly complex, and in the other, the child turned out to have multiple highly special medical needs.

With two young kids at home already, we have to make the decision that will be best for everyone. If we don’t feel equipped to handle a placement, we aren’t doing anyone any favors by accepting. That being said, I still think about those two kids regularly, and I never even met them.

Recently, you fostered a baby you were hoping to adopt and the baby’s grandparents opted to adopt the baby. How did you manage that grief? How do your boys feel about this?

Our placement with the baby was crazy. We were selected for him before he’d even been taken into custody. After a few days, they actually issued an amber alert for him. My heart jumped into my throat when I saw the mug shots of his parents come up on the TV. It was surreal when our cell phones buzzed with the break-through amber alert notification.

The baby was located that night, and we met him at the hospital. He was extremely underweight and had suffered a serious physical injury. But he was beautiful and happy.

We stayed with him in the hospital for three days, then brought him home for four days. We all fell in love with him immediately. Then the other shoe dropped: the agency hadn’t been totally forthcoming. The baby had grandparents who initially declined to take him. Then they changed their minds.

I had a day before court to write up everything I knew about the baby, everything we’d been through in the hospital, and basically said we’d love to keep him. (This wasn’t required; it was my own desperate action.) Our Crossnore supervisor said the judge and everyone in the court read it (I wasn’t there, though I was legally allowed to be; we had a doctor appointment at the same time). But the judge moved him to his grandparents anyway.

I got the call at the appointment, and his social worker asked if I could bring him to the courthouse. I said no. I left, picked up my kids and called my husband so they could all come home and say goodbye, and our supervisor came and picked him up from our house.

He was gone less than two hours after the court ruling.

For the first couple of weeks, the grief was profound. It had begun to feel natural when people referred to me as his mama. He slept in the bassinet my two biological sons had slept in. He wore their little onesies. I had begun to imagine the future of our family with him in it, forever. So I had to grieve not having the baby anymore, but I also had to grieve the future we had lost.

For a month, I kept getting calls from doctors about him, and I had to keep telling people he wasn’t with us anymore. My 4-year-old kept asking where the baby was and saying he wanted him, for like, weeks. That was rough. My 9-year-old confided in a classmate and his teacher, and he’s not usually a big feelings sharer.

We holed up (but didn’t withdraw) and did a lot of self-care: staying in as a family, eating good meals, doing things we enjoyed like watching movies and reading. It just takes time.

What tools/books/websites/resources have helped you navigate this?

Crossnore holds a monthly foster parent support group, and that helps immensely. I can’t say enough about the importance of trauma-informed training. It’s helped me be a better parent all around. It also helps to have excellent “natural supports”—a few close friends and family members.

Reading about foster care can be insanely depressing. One of the books I found to be most realistic but also hopeful was “Another Place at the Table” by Kathy Harrison.

What have you learned from this that ANY of us could apply to our daily lives?

Everyone could benefit from good mental hygiene. It’s important to internalize the reality that most people’s behavior toward you isn’t personal. Books by Brene Brown and Gretchen Rubin are my go-to favorites, and I’ve recently started meditating. I like the 15-minute guided meditation called Expanding Love by the Self-Realization Fellowship on YouTube.

On a practical level: babies will always blow out their diapers and kids will always be starving in the most awkward moments. Have a snack (we like Kind granola bars) and, for a baby, a diaper and change of clothes in the car, plus an on-the-go formula pack and an empty bottle.

Finally, the hardest things are the most rewarding. The strongest things are the most flexible. And the Serenity Prayer is for real, y’all.

Thank you so much for sharing your story, Erin. Do you guys have any questions for her?

P.S. Two more sides to the family story: I met my birth mom and I went through the foster care system.

Welcome to Yes & Yes!

Want to spend your time, money, and energy on purpose? I'll show you how.

You might also like…

True Story: I Did Teach For America

True Story: I Did Teach For America

What's it like to do Teach For America? Would you ever want to become a classroom teacher in a low-income area ... after five weeks of training? That's exactly what Samantha did! This is her story. Tell us a bit about yourself!  My name is Samantha. I'm from Michigan,...

read more
True Story: I Reinvented Myself at 50

True Story: I Reinvented Myself at 50

What does it mean to reinvent yourself and your life at 50? I know sooooo many people who feel trapped in their lives or career and they're not even 35! I LOVED this interview Judy and I think you will, too. Tell us a bit about yourself! Hi! I'm originally a New...

read more
True Story: I lost my hand, leg, and sight to sepsis

True Story: I lost my hand, leg, and sight to sepsis

How would you navigate life if you lost your leg, hand, and eyesight to a surprise infection ... while you were pregnant? How would you cope with re-learning how to walk, parent, be a partner after something like that? That's exactly what happened to Carol in 2008....

read more


  1. Rebekah Jaunty

    This was lovely. I wish Erin and her family the best of everything!

  2. Lesley S

    Thank you SO much for sharing your experience. My husband and I are hoping to start the foster to adopt classes in our area this summer. I work in a pediatric Rehab facility in Appalachia. Roughly 50% of our patients are in foster care due to the devastating opioid epidemic. I’ve seen with our patients how wonderful it is when children become a part of a loving and supportive family. All the best to you and your family!

    • Sarah Von Bargen

      Oh, that’s so great, Lesley! And thank you for doing such important work! <3

  3. Rachel King

    This was wonderful! I’ve always wanted to adopt so it’s great to hear about another way of doing so and learning about the process. Erin and her family sound lovely, best of luck to them.

  4. Sarah

    Thank you to Erin for sharing her experience! I have seen first hand how heart breaking yet rewarding foster care can be. I’m a Social Worker and foster to adopt programs are such a complicated issue. In Alabama, and I can only assume other states, the primary goal of foster care is to reunite children with their biological families. This is why fostering to adopt can frequently end up in heart break for foster/adoptive parents. Sending my love to all families willing to risk this heart break to help children find their forever homes.

  5. Jasmine Caldwell

    Amazing story!!! I went through foster care also, but it was a story to tell I’m just happy to be alive with great kids now. Thank you god!!

Pin It on Pinterest